Key Takeaways

• Asking about current coverage status at the very start of a Medicare conversation sets the foundation for the entire appointment.

• Without this critical question, you risk wasting time explaining options that may not even apply to the client’s actual enrollment situation.

---

Start with the One Question That Guides Everything Else

Before you talk about Medicare Advantage, Medigap, or drug plans, you need to ask this simple but crucial question:

“Are you currently enrolled in Medicare, and if so, which parts?”

This question unlocks the rest of the appointment. It determines whether you’re educating, enrolling, or troubleshooting. And yet, many agents either skip it, ask it too late, or phrase it in a way that’s confusing to clients. The result? You end up backtracking and repeating yourself—often under a ticking clock.

Why This Question Matters More Than Ever in 2025

In 2025, Medicare clients face even more complexity than in previous years. Between the updated Part D rules, the ongoing PSHB transition for postal retirees, and changes in Medicare Advantage supplemental benefits, you cannot afford to make assumptions. A person who says, “I’m on Medicare,” might mean any of the following:

• Enrolled in Part A only

• Enrolled in both A and B

• Enrolled in A and B with a standalone drug plan

• Enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan (Part C)

• Dual eligible for Medicaid and Medicare

• Covered through a group plan while delaying Part B

• Recently switched or disenrolled from a plan

If you don’t clarify upfront, you risk explaining irrelevant coverage options or missing enrollment limitations.

---

What the Question Reveals (and Why It Saves Time)

When you ask about current enrollment status, you gain essential insights instantly:

• Eligibility for new plans: If the client already has Medicare Parts A and B, they’re eligible for Advantage or Medigap.

• Enrollment window status: If they delayed Part B or are about to turn 65, different timelines apply.

• Possible penalties: If they missed an enrollment window, you can explain the consequences now—not 45 minutes into the meeting.

• Drug plan coordination: Part D eligibility depends on Part A or B status.

• COBRA and employer coordination: Knowing whether they’re still covered through work helps clarify what applies.

This saves you from circling back and reexplaining everything in a different context. Instead, you move forward with clarity.

---

How to Phrase the Question So Clients Actually Understand It

Asking “Are you on Medicare?” is not enough. That often results in vague or inaccurate answers. Instead, break it down. Here are more effective ways to ask:

• “Are you currently enrolled in Medicare Part A (hospital) and/or Part B (doctor visits)?”

• “Do you have a Medicare card? What date does it show for Part A and Part B?”

• “Have you signed up for any additional Medicare plans, like a drug plan or health plan through a private company?”

Avoid jargon. Don’t assume they know what “Part C” or “Medigap” means. Keep the language clear and refer to the parts by function (hospital, doctor, drug coverage, etc.).

---

When to Ask It: Timing Is Everything

The first 3 minutes of your appointment are crucial. That’s your opportunity to set the stage and avoid future confusion. After greetings and small talk, lead with the enrollment question.

This is especially important in:

• Annual Enrollment Period (Oct 15–Dec 7): You need to confirm what plan the client is currently on before suggesting any changes.

• Turning 65 consultations: You must establish whether they’ve signed up already or are still considering their options.

• Special Enrollment Period cases: Knowing if a client recently moved, lost employer coverage, or qualified for Medicaid changes what they can enroll in and when.

Asking too late means you may have spent 20 minutes discussing plans they aren’t eligible for or don’t need.

---

Follow-Up Questions That Keep the Appointment on Track

Once you confirm their current enrollment status, you can immediately build on it with strategic follow-up questions. These help you stay efficient:

• “Did you enroll in Medicare yourself, or were you automatically enrolled?”

• “Have you reviewed your plan recently, or is it the same one you’ve had for a few years?”

• “Do you have any coverage through a retirement system, union, or former employer?”

• “Are you taking any medications regularly that we should make sure are covered?”

This keeps you in control of the flow, builds rapport, and positions you as the knowledgeable professional clients can trust.

---

Common Pitfalls When You Skip the Question

Failing to ask about current Medicare enrollment can derail an appointment in multiple ways:

• Wasted time: You might spend 30 minutes reviewing options for a person who isn’t even eligible yet.

• Compliance risk: Giving plan-specific recommendations to someone not properly enrolled can cross CMS boundaries.

• Client confusion: When you explain options that don’t apply, the client leaves more confused than they came in.

• Lost sales: Misunderstanding their status can lead to mismatched plans, disenrollment, or clients choosing someone else.

In short: backtracking costs you efficiency and credibility. And in a business driven by trust and timing, that’s not a risk worth taking.

---

Your First 10 Minutes Should Be a Scripted System

To prevent missed opportunities, treat the first 10 minutes like a structured sequence:

1. Warm greeting

2. Confirm appointment purpose

3. Ask about current Medicare enrollment (Parts A, B, D, Advantage, or other)

4. Clarify if they’re working or retired

5. Ask if they have employer or union coverage

6. Ask if they receive any financial assistance (Medicaid, Extra Help, etc.)

Only after these basics should you begin talking about plan options or giving advice. This upfront structure reduces confusion, aligns expectations, and speeds up the appointment.

---

Why This Matters More in 2025

In 2025, new rules and market dynamics make early clarification even more essential:

• Medicare Part D now has a $2,000 annual out-of-pocket cap – Only applies to those enrolled in drug coverage.

• Postal retirees have transitioned to the PSHB system – Requires careful coordination with Medicare Part B.

• Enrollment flexibility for Special Needs Plans has narrowed – Requires timely confirmation of dual eligibility.

• Annual notices have changed – Many clients don’t read them, so you need to verify information directly.

Every appointment starts with uncertainty, and it’s your job to bring structure. A single question brings that structure faster than anything else.

---

Clients Rarely Know Their Status Clearly—You Must Investigate

Don’t assume your clients understand their coverage. Many people say, “I have Medicare,” when they only have Part A. Others assume their employer plan “comes with Medicare.” Some believe Advantage plans are “just Medicare.” You’re not being intrusive—you’re being professional by verifying.

Ask for the Medicare card. Ask for plan paperwork. Explain the differences between Parts A, B, C, and D without assuming prior knowledge. In 2025, misinformation spreads fast. Precision matters.

---

Build a Repeatable Process for Every Client

You don’t need to reinvent your approach each time. Create a checklist that includes:

• Medicare card verification

• Employer coverage check

• Plan review (if already enrolled)

• Medicaid/Extra Help status

• Prescription list

By systematizing your opening routine, you reduce errors and increase confidence—both yours and your client’s.

---

Getting Aligned Early Prevents Missed Opportunities

When you ask the enrollment question early, you:

• Avoid time-wasting backtracking

• Customize your pitch to their situation

• Prevent compliance mistakes

• Close sales faster

• Increase client satisfaction and retention

It’s not just a procedural improvement. It’s the difference between a frustrating conversation and a productive, results-driven one.

---

Aligning Your Appointments with Clarity from the Start

You only get one chance to start each appointment right. The Medicare landscape in 2025 is dense with detail, deadlines, and dependencies. That’s why the very first question should establish clarity: What coverage do you currently have?

We built BedrockMD to help independent agents like you bring consistency to this process. Our platform supports structured client intake, accurate plan tracking, and ongoing education—so you spend more time advising and less time correcting misunderstandings.

Sign up today and see how we can help you build a repeatable, effective Medicare business that gets it right from the first question.