Key Takeaways
-
You don’t need to make Medicare penalties a scary conversation. The key is to shift the focus from fear to informed planning.
-
Starting with a simple timeline and reinforcing client control can make the topic easier to absorb and act on.
Start With What They Can Control
When the topic of Medicare penalties comes up, it can feel heavy, even confrontational. But it doesn’t have to be. Instead of warning your clients about late enrollment penalties upfront, frame the conversation around what they can do.
Start here:
-
Emphasize their choices in enrollment.
-
Clarify the timelines for each part of Medicare.
-
Reassure them that you’re there to help them avoid unnecessary costs.
This approach does more than ease tension. It builds trust.
Understand the Structure Before You Explain It
You can’t explain what you don’t fully understand. As an independent agent, it’s your responsibility to clearly communicate the three most common Medicare penalties:
-
Part A late enrollment penalty (rare, but relevant for those not eligible for premium-free Part A).
-
Part B late enrollment penalty (most common and longest-lasting).
-
Part D late enrollment penalty (frequently misunderstood).
Get clear on the following for each:
-
What triggers the penalty.
-
How long it lasts.
-
How it’s calculated.
Once you’re grounded in those specifics, your delivery will feel less scripted and more confident.
Medicare Part A: The Rare but Real Penalty
Most people qualify for premium-free Part A based on their work history or their spouse’s. But if someone isn’t eligible and chooses not to enroll when first eligible, they may face a penalty.
-
Trigger: Delayed enrollment without qualifying coverage.
-
Penalty Amount: 10% of the monthly premium.
-
Penalty Duration: Paid for twice the number of years the client delayed enrollment.
This is not a common penalty, but if your client doesn’t have a long work history, bring it up gently. Focus on eligibility first, then move to consequences if needed.
Medicare Part B: The One That Lingers
This is the penalty most clients know about, but not in detail. The Part B late enrollment penalty can significantly raise costs over time, especially since it never goes away.
-
Trigger: Not enrolling in Part B when first eligible and going without creditable coverage.
-
Penalty Amount: 10% of the standard premium for each 12-month period of delay.
-
Penalty Duration: For life.
Here’s how to make it less intimidating:
-
Focus on how to avoid the penalty.
-
Break down the Initial Enrollment Period (IEP): 3 months before, the month of, and 3 months after the 65th birthday.
-
Mention Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs) for those working past 65 with employer coverage.
Explain that enrolling late without creditable coverage doesn’t just mean paying more—it means paying more every single year for the rest of their life. Let that land gently.
Medicare Part D: The Most Overlooked Penalty
Prescription drug coverage is easy to overlook when clients are healthy. But skipping Part D can lead to a frustrating penalty down the road.
-
Trigger: Going 63 days or more without creditable prescription drug coverage after becoming eligible.
-
Penalty Amount: 1% of the national base premium times the number of full, uncovered months.
-
Penalty Duration: For as long as the client has Medicare drug coverage.
Your clients don’t need to pick a comprehensive plan right away, but they do need to avoid a gap. Here’s what to emphasize:
-
Any creditable coverage counts.
-
Even a low-cost plan can protect them from the penalty.
-
Once incurred, the penalty is recalculated annually and can increase.
Let your clients know that avoiding this penalty is often as simple as staying covered.
Help Clients Identify What Coverage Counts
A major source of confusion is understanding what “creditable coverage” means.
Make this simple:
-
Part B: Employer coverage from a company with 20+ employees counts.
-
Part D: Employer or union coverage must be as good as Medicare drug coverage to be creditable.
Encourage clients to ask their HR departments for a creditable coverage notice. And let them know you’re available to interpret it with them.
Use Timelines, Not Threats
Instead of leading with “If you don’t do this, you’ll pay,” build a timeline:
-
Turning 65 soon? Start planning 6 months before.
-
Still working? Find out if their employer coverage is creditable.
-
Not working? Recommend signing up during the IEP.
-
Already missed the IEP? Discuss the next available General Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31), with coverage starting July 1.
When you map it out like this, the decision feels more manageable.
Frame the Conversation Around Value, Not Penalty
People don’t respond well to being told they’re about to make a mistake. They respond better to learning how to make the right choice.
Instead of focusing on avoiding penalties:
-
Talk about the value of continuous coverage.
-
Explain how being proactive saves them money long-term.
-
Reinforce their ability to make informed decisions.
When clients feel like you’re helping them gain control, they listen.
Handle Past Mistakes Without Shame
You may have clients who are already dealing with a penalty. Don’t shy away from it—but don’t dwell on it either.
Here’s how to move forward:
-
Validate their frustration without assigning blame.
-
Explain the math behind the penalty and how it’s calculated.
-
Focus on what can be done next—not what was missed.
Clients will appreciate your directness and your empathy. That balance builds lasting loyalty.
Speak Plainly, But Don’t Dumb It Down
Medicare penalties are complex, but your clients are capable of understanding them. The secret is language:
-
Avoid acronyms unless you define them.
-
Break each concept into a single idea per sentence.
-
Use visual aids when helpful—timelines, charts, enrollment windows.
Clarity, not oversimplification, should be your goal.
Review Each Year
Don’t wait until a penalty hits to revisit Medicare timelines with your clients.
Use your annual reviews to:
-
Double-check creditable coverage.
-
Confirm drug coverage is in place.
-
Discuss any changes in work status that might affect enrollment.
This reinforces your value, ensures compliance, and keeps penalties off the table.
Make the Hard Stuff Part of the Routine
When you consistently include penalty education in your Medicare discussions, it becomes less awkward—for you and your client. You’re not springing bad news on them. You’re preparing them early.
Make the following a standard part of your process:
-
Ask if they have coverage through work or elsewhere.
-
Check if they’ve received a creditable coverage notice.
-
Confirm if they’re past their IEP and what actions they’ve taken.
The earlier you bring it up, the smoother everything else goes.
Talking Medicare Penalties Means Building Confidence
Medicare penalties are real, and they can cost your clients thousands over time. But the topic doesn’t have to feel punitive or awkward. When you start with facts, show empathy, and provide clear steps, you position yourself not just as a salesperson—but as a trusted advocate.
If you’re ready to strengthen how you serve Medicare clients, sign up on BedrockMD. We provide tools, training, and ongoing support that help professionals like you hold better conversations, earn more trust, and retain more clients.
